What Should My Doctor Write for an LTD Appeal?

By Adam Olszeski, Davis Olszeski LLP

Published August 4, 2026

Quick Summary: If your long-term disability benefits were denied or terminated, ask your doctor to explain what your medical condition prevents you from doing, how often those limitations occur, and why they interfere with reliable work. A detailed opinion that connects restrictions to treatment records and job duties can directly address an insurer’s conclusion that you can return to work.

A diagnosis alone is often not enough in a long-term disability, or LTD, appeal. The insurer may agree that you have a medical condition while maintaining that you can still perform sedentary work, concentrate adequately, or work full time. For that reason, your doctor’s documentation should focus on function: what you can and cannot do consistently in a work setting.

Davis Olszeski LLP helps clients in St. Louis, Missouri, and throughout the Midwest evaluate ERISA disability denials and prepare appeals that respond to an insurer’s stated rationale.

Start With the Reason Your LTD Benefits Were Denied

Before asking your doctor for a letter or form, read the denial or termination letter closely. Identify what the insurance company says you can still do. Did it conclude that you can sit long enough for desk work? Did it state that the records do not show problems with concentration, attendance, or stamina? Did it rely on a reviewing physician’s opinion or a vocational assessment?

Give your doctor the relevant portion of the denial letter, along with a clear description of your job duties. If your policy has transitioned from an own-occupation definition of disability to an any-occupation definition, provide information about the alternative jobs identified by the insurer. Your provider does not need to become a vocational expert, but understanding the work demands can help them explain whether your medical limitations are consistent with sustained employment.

What Should a Doctor’s Disability Letter Include?

Ask your doctor to address the following topics within their clinical expertise and to explain the medical basis for their conclusions. Specific, supportable information is generally more useful than broad statements that a patient is “disabled.”

The Relevant Time Period

Your doctor should identify when the limitations began and whether they were present during the period the insurer claims you could return to work. If the opinion addresses an earlier period, it should identify the treatment records, examinations, testing, or observations that support the retrospective assessment.

Specific Restrictions and Limitations

A strong opinion describes what symptoms prevent you from doing. Depending on the condition, that may include how long you can sit, stand, walk, type, use your hands, speak, drive, or concentrate before symptoms interfere. It may also address whether you need to change positions, take unscheduled breaks, lie down, avoid certain activities, or limit exposure to light, noise, stress, or other triggers.

The estimates should be medically supportable. A provider should not feel pressured to supply exact limits that are not supported by the clinical record. But where reasonable estimates are available, they can help translate a diagnosis into work-related functional limitations.

Frequency, Severity, and Recovery Time

Many disabling conditions fluctuate. A doctor’s statement can explain how often symptom flares occur, how long they last, what triggers them, and what recovery is required afterward. This is especially important when pain, fatigue, migraines, dizziness, gastrointestinal symptoms, autoimmune flares, or neurological symptoms make regular attendance difficult.

The opinion can also address treatment side effects that affect work, such as sedation, slowed thinking, nausea, impaired coordination, or the need for frequent medical appointments. The ability to complete an activity once is not necessarily the ability to repeat it reliably throughout a workday and workweek.

The Effect on Essential Job Duties

The letter should connect the documented restrictions to actual work demands. For example, an accounting employee may perform desk work, but the job may also require sustained attention to multistep tasks, accuracy, deadlines, and consistent productivity. If fatigue or cognitive symptoms limit concentration, the provider can explain how long the employee can sustain attention, what occurs when activity continues beyond that point, and how much recovery time is typically needed.

That type of explanation helps the insurer evaluate whether the employee can reconcile accounts accurately, meet deadlines, and maintain performance over a normal workweek—not simply whether the employee can sit at a computer.

Clinical Support for the Opinion

A doctor’s statement should identify the evidence supporting the restrictions and limitations. This may include examination findings, imaging or laboratory results, treatment history, medication trials, specialist evaluations, and the provider’s observations over time.

If the insurer relied on a “normal” finding, it may be helpful for the provider to explain what that finding measures and whether it addresses the specific work-capacity question at issue. For example, a normal strength examination may not answer whether a person can sustain concentration, maintain attendance, tolerate pain, or work after repeated activity without a significant symptom increase.

What If My Doctor Will Complete a Form but Not Write a Letter?

Many providers have limited time and may prefer to complete an attending physician statement or document restrictions in a visit note rather than prepare a separate letter. Those options can still be valuable if they address the insurer’s specific concerns.

Ask whether the provider can attach a short explanation to the form or include functional limitations in the medical record. A treating specialist, therapist, or other clinician may also be able to document limitations they have personally evaluated. Bring the relevant denial rationale and a short list of focused questions to the appointment, and give the provider adequate time to review the request.

Does an ERISA Plan Have to Accept My Doctor’s Opinion?

ERISA does not require a plan administrator to give special weight to a treating doctor’s opinion. In Black & Decker Disability Plan v. Nord , 538 U.S. 822 (2003), the Supreme Court held that ERISA does not impose a treating-physician rule. At the same time, plan administrators may not arbitrarily refuse to credit reliable evidence.

For disability benefit claims, federal claims-procedure rules require an adverse determination to include a discussion of the decision, including the basis for disagreeing with or not following views presented by treating health-care professionals and vocational professionals. See 29 C.F.R. § 2560.503-1(g)(1)(vii)(A)(i) and (j)(6)(i)(A).

When Should I Begin Gathering Medical Evidence?

Start as soon as you receive a denial or termination notice. ERISA disability plans generally must provide at least 180 days from receipt of an adverse benefit determination to submit an appeal. Check your denial letter and plan documents for the applicable deadline and submission instructions.

You may request, free of charge, reasonable access to relevant documents, records, and other information related to your claim. Starting the request early gives you time to review the insurer’s rationale, speak with your providers, and submit evidence that addresses the specific findings used to deny benefits.

Davis Olszeski LLP represents individuals whose employer-sponsored long-term disability benefits have been denied or terminated. We review denial letters, plan documents, and claim-file evidence to help identify what an ERISA disability appeal may need.

FAQ

What is the most important thing my doctor should explain?

Your doctor should explain how your condition limits your ability to perform work activities reliably, including the frequency of symptoms, need for breaks, recovery time, and effect on attendance or concentration.

Should I give my doctor the insurance company’s denial letter?

Yes. Providing the relevant portions of the letter can help your doctor address the insurer’s stated reasons for denying or terminating benefits.

Can a doctor use estimates when describing restrictions?

Yes, when the estimates are medically supportable. Specific limits can be helpful, but they should be grounded in the provider’s treatment records, examinations, and clinical judgment.

How long do I have to appeal an ERISA LTD denial?

ERISA disability plans generally provide at least 180 days after you receive an adverse benefit determination, but you should confirm the deadline in your denial letter and plan documents.

This article provides general information and is not legal advice. For advice about a specific claim, consult an attorney.